Day 2

[luminos]

NO, that does not count. Play the game, give reasons. Don't just say, quit lynching me get someone else.

[THodges]

-sigh- someone who says their important won't play and seems scummy

[eritas]

Well seems like funkii confirms rawr being something important
Unvote rawr. Vote kelsie.

[luminos]

I doubt Funkii confirmed that. If it was that easy, all we'd have to do is fake claim everything we aren't, and we'd figure out what everyone was by Funkii not throwing anyone out.

[luminos]

And anyhoo, I'm against a Kelsie vote

[eritas]

Well, it seems to me that it was a mistake as to what is acceptable game play. Granted it happened, but I'm all for using that to our advantage. I'm willing to follow rawr today tbh.

[luminos]

Rawr is either fail town or fail mafia. Following him makes no sense either way. I can see a case for not lynching her, but at least pick a lynch that makes sense.

[eritas]

Rawr is a her, btw.

[luminos]

I have a feeling this can get screwed up nine ways to hell, and I'm not sure what to do in the situation. I'm not putting my vote on Rawr as I promised I would at this deadline, and I'm not jumping on the kelsie bandwaggon either.

If Rawr really can't say more than a few short sentences, then what use is she even if she is a PR? I would think her lack of activity would mean she isn't a PR, it shows boredom, but she has apparently made enough of a claim to be censored. So now she is trolling as either a PR or as mafia, both which are not likely, but they are the only options we have for the moment.

I can see two options:

One, we stick with a Rawr lynch until some justification comes (and it won't because she is trolling). Perhaps we lynch her and see she is mafia and celebrate one of the worst mafia plays imaginable. Or we find she is town, and a whole bunch of us look really bad for leading on someone that soft-claimed pretty hard and that got away with a warning for hard claiming
(which should not have happened. Funkii, I do not know to interpret that warning as saying don't make any hard claims, or don't make a true claim. That could really mess things up as far as what we are allowed to do.)

Two, we try to lead a last minute lynch on someone else. We have 11 hours to do this, and during most of this time everyone will be asleep. The new lynch may have almost no time for a reaction/soft claim, and mafia could easily use the confusion to subtly influence the balance of votes onto the person they want dead.

Both options are absolutely horrible at the moment. I will be setting my alarm for early in the morning, to see if there is any damage control that can be done at that point. But to me, the least damaging option would be to go with a known weak point, and that is rawr.

I'm not actually making a vote at this point, just to be clear.

[kelsielove]

Thanks luminos. But i disagree about lynching rawr. If rawr was soft claiming she would be claiming a town role if she was trying in anyway to defend herself (which she was). She obviously is a pr and as such will be killed tonight anyway. I say we use our vote on someone who could possibly be mafia. Either way we get our wish and rawr dies.

Also I am PeterMaudDib for the person who asked earlier.

I unvote rawr which is ironic since i never meant to officially vote her in the first place

"I agree with the vote on rawr but i really would like rawr to give a defense to why we shouldn't take her life before I vote."

I apologize for the mis-communication there.

and i will get back to you on who i do vote

[kelsielove]

Jun 18, 2010 20:10:17 GMT -5 belthazar666 said:

I think I've figured something out. Nothing significant, just a little something that says I really shouldn't be pushing this button; nor should anyone else.

Not pushing it.

I can't get over this post. Its screams anti town. I put it above rawrs push it comment. As such i give my vote to belthazar666 for lynching. Everything he has said has been ambiguous and unhelpful. His posts are rather short and his reasoning is null.

KelsieLove votes belthazar666

[laexio]

My vote stands on rawr. She hasn't given reasons for asking us to vote kelsie, just assumed we'd believe she's some sort of town PR and demanded we vote her. I don't think rawr asking us to vote her has anything to do with her role, otherwise she would've some something sooner.

[doomedjellyfish]

What a mess. How I see it, Rarw is a confirmed PR now, and I think she is town. Unfortunately.

I am not defending Kelsie, but I would be more comfortable with a Belth lynch also. As I said before, it would have been better for town to push the button. Yet Belth hardclaimed to know more about the stuation and still advocated for not pushing it. He hasn't said all that much either, even after I brought his actions up on page 9. He posted on page 11 and did not acknowledge anything I brought up.

[Funkii]

Well guys I have some news, Rawr officially resigned from the game last night. No she was not trolling the game she was super busy with soccer and school and stuff and I totally understand. The night phase and the next section of the story will be up soon.